Net-Net Value Investing
Imagine stumbling upon a treasure chest filled with gold coins, jewels, and priceless artifacts. In the world of investing, finding undervalued stocks can evoke a similar thrill.
One timeless strategy, championed by legendary investors like Benjamin Graham, offers the excitement of discovering hidden gems: Net-Net Investing.
This method zeroes in on stocks trading at prices lower than their net current asset value (NCAV), offering a unique path to uncovering these elusive treasures.
What is Net-Net Investing?
Net-Net Investing isn't just about numbers; it's a quest for undervalued opportunities that others have overlooked.
At its core, this strategy involves buying stocks of companies trading for less than their net current asset value (NCAV). The formula to calculate NCAV is:
NCAV = Current Assets − Total Liabilities
Picture a company’s balance sheet as a treasure map. By focusing on the most liquid assets (like cash, inventory, and receivables) and subtracting all liabilities, we reveal the treasure's true value.
Investing in stocks priced below this value means buying into a company where the sum of its most liquid assets exceeds the market's current valuation, providing a built-in margin of safety.
Step-by-Step Guide to Net-Net Investing
Identify Potential Stocks: Begin your search by looking for companies with a low price-to-book ratio, ideally under 1.
Calculate NCAV: Use the company’s balance sheet to subtract total liabilities from current assets.
Compare NCAV to Market Price: Ensure the stock price is less than the NCAV.
Evaluate the Business: Confirm the company is not in a terminal decline and has some potential for recovery.
Calculation example
To illustrate the concept, let's look at two hypothetical companies: Company A and Company B.
Company A (Under-valuation)
Current Assets: $1,000,000
Total Liabilities: $600,000
Shares Outstanding: 100,000
Stock Price: $3
First, calculate the NCAV per share:
NCAV = $1,000,000 − $600,000 = $400,000
NCAV per Share = $400,000 / 100,000 = $4
Company A's stock price is $3, below the NCAV per share of $4.
This signals under-valuation according to Net-Net criteria.
Investors might see Company A as a buried treasure, trading at a discount to its net current asset value.
Company B (Over-valuation)
Current Assets: $2,000,000
Total Liabilities: $1,500,000
Shares Outstanding: 200,000
Stock Price: $5
Now, calculate the NCAV per share:
NCAV = $2,000,000 − $1,500,000 = $500,000
NCAV per Share = $500,000 / 200,000 = $2.50
Company B’s stock price is $5, much higher than the NCAV per share of $2.50, indicating over-valuation.
Investors might steer clear of Company B’s stock since it doesn't meet the Net-Net Investing criteria.
The Warren Buffett Perspective on Net-Net Investing
Warren Buffett, one of the most successful investors of all time, began his career by adhering to Benjamin Graham’s principles, including Net-Net Investing.
Buffett often looked for stocks trading at less than two-thirds of their NCAV, providing an even larger margin of safety.
Example:
Current Assets: $1,500,000
Total Liabilities: $1,000,000
Shares Outstanding: 150,000
Stock Price: $2
Calculate the NCAV per share:
NCAV = $1,500,000 − $1,000,000 = $500,000
NCAV per Share = $500,000 / 150,000 = $3.33
For Buffett’s criteria: 2/3 NCAV per Share = 2/3 × $3.33 ≈ $2.222
With a stock price of $2, this company meets Buffett's criteria as it is trading below two-thirds of its NCAV, making it an attractive investment.
Potential Risks and Shortcomings of Net-Net Investing
While Net-Net Investing can be rewarding, it comes with its own set of risks and potential shortcomings:
Quality of Assets: The strategy assumes that current assets are easily liquidated at their book value. In reality, some assets, like inventory or receivables, might not fetch their book value in a distressed sale.
Business Decline: Many Net-Net stocks are companies in financial trouble or in declining industries. Investing in such companies carries the risk that they may never recover.
Market Conditions: In a bull market, finding Net-Net opportunities can be challenging as stock prices generally rise, pushing valuations above NCAV.
Liquidity Issues: Net-Net stocks are often small-cap or micro-cap stocks, which can have low trading volumes, making it difficult to buy or sell large quantities without affecting the stock price.
Management Quality: Companies trading below NCAV might have poor management, which could hinder their ability to recover or unlock shareholder value.
Conclusion
Net-Net Investing offers a time-tested approach to uncovering undervalued stocks with a margin of safety. By focusing on companies trading below their net current asset value, investors can find hidden gems that others might overlook.
Remember, the key to success with this strategy is thorough research and careful evaluation of a company's financial health and business prospects.
So, next time you’re looking for investment opportunities, consider diving into the world of Net-Net Investing. With patience and diligence, you might just find the next hidden treasure in the stock market.
Stay inspired!
Read more:
—
Interested to learn more about business, investments and personal growth? Subscribe to our free newsletter.
Need help to launch, grow or exit your business? Looking for a safe pair of hands to carry it to greater heights? Get in touch.